WNC'S CALEB JOHNSON HANGS IN THERE ON "AMERICAN IDOL"

WNC'S CALEB JOHNSON HANGS IN THERE ON "AMERICAN IDOL" WNC'S CALEB JOHNSON HANGS IN THERE ON "AMERICAN IDOL"

 

The Asheville Citizen-Times reports on Friday that Western North Carolina rocker Caleb Johnson is safe to sing another week on “American Idol.”

 

The rocker, who sang Lady Gaga’s “Edge of Glory” on Wednesday’s live performance show, was not the singer with the lowest viewer vote total, who was eliminated on Thursday’s results show.

That singer was MK Nobilette, who sang Pink’s “Perfect.”

Johnson, 22, has consistently been among the best singers on the competition, although as the field narrows he is no longer guaranteed to be the one most lauded by the judges.

On Wednesday, although judge Harry Connick Jr. graded his rocking rendition of “Glory” and A or A-plus, he added, “I’ve seen you do better.”

Judge Keith Urban was even less complementary. Although he said that Johnson is sure to “deliver every week,” Urban compared the singer’s driving rock singing style to a locomotive and said that Wednesday’s performance was “lumbering instead of motoring.” He also commented on its “imbalance.”

Jennifer Lopez said she didn’t think Johnson was connecting with the lyrics of the song. “It was lacking the feeling for me,” she said.

Fellow contestants Alex Preston, Malaya Watson, Majesty Rose (also from North Carolina) and Sam Woolf got judges’ comments that were at least as positive or more laudatory than those Johnson received.

The Top 9 contestants will next sing at 8 p.m. March 26 on a two-hour live show. The voting tallies will be reviewed on a results show shortened to 30 minutes, from an hour, and airing at 9 p.m. March 27.